THE LOCKE LEDGER.
Independent thinking about the work behind the work

Playbook

What Should a Store Send on Cyber Monday?

Two emails, one text and three settings decide whether the last call reaches the people it is meant for.

By Monday morning a store knows who bought, what sold out and who looked without buying. That record, more than any national forecast, should decide the day's sends.

Cyber Monday was again the biggest day for online spending in the United States last year. Adobe, which says its analytics run on the sites of most of the 100 largest online retailers in the United States, counted $14.25 billion on December 1, 2025, up 7.1 percent from the year before. Its forecast for Monday, November 30, 2026 is $15.1 billion.

Adobe's reports also show that Black Friday has grown faster than Cyber Monday for two seasons running: 9.1 percent against 7.1 percent in 2025, and 10.2 percent against 7.3 percent in 2024. Adobe expects the pattern to hold in 2026, at 9.2 percent against 6.2 percent. Adobe credits shoppers who took early deals.

For a small store, then, the Cyber Monday email closes an offer most of the list has already seen. The sends go to the people who looked and did not buy, and the store writes them with three days of its own results in hand.

What the national numbers can tell a small store

Adobe's figures describe a market weighted toward large retailers. Its 2025 figures come from more than 1 trillion visits to American retail sites, and electronics, apparel and furniture made up 57 percent of Cyber Monday spending in 2025. A shop that sells candles or dog treats sits inside that total without looking much like it.

Some findings still carry over, as patterns rather than forecasts for any one store:

  • The day is shopped on phones. Mobile devices carried 57.5 percent of Adobe's Cyber Monday spending in 2025. The National Retail Federation (NRF) and Prosper Insights & Analytics estimated from a survey that 75.9 million people shopped online on Cyber Monday that year, 46.9 million of them on a mobile device.
  • The day runs late. Adobe reported that Cyber Monday spending peaked between 8 p.m. and 10 p.m., at $16 million a minute. Its release did not say which time zone.
  • Monday draws fewer shoppers than Friday. NRF's survey estimated 85.7 million online shoppers on Black Friday 2025, against 75.9 million on Cyber Monday.

Shopify's report on its own merchants also puts the top of the weekend on Friday. Shopify said its merchants sold $14.6 billion over the 2025 Black Friday and Cyber Monday weekend, with the peak at 12:01 p.m. Eastern on Black Friday, at $5.1 million a minute. That figure counts stores of every size, worldwide, in person and online, so it describes the platform rather than any one shop.

The best guide to a store's own Monday is its own last Cyber Monday. If the store ran a sale on December 1, 2025, its order history shows when those orders came in.

Start Monday with what the weekend showed

On Thanksgiving the store could only guess how the offer would land. The weekend's orders and clicks now answer that.

Who bought. Everyone who has ordered since Thanksgiving comes off the Monday sale emails. A customer who gets "last chance" after paying learns that the store's emails are not written for them. Order and shipping updates still go out as usual.

What sold out. Remove any product that is nearly sold out from the emails and from the top of the homepage. The Black Friday merchandising piece explains how to pick the products a sale leads with. On Monday, correct that choice with the weekend's sales.

Who looked and did not buy. This group is Monday's main audience. A segment is a part of the store's email or text audience chosen by what those people did or bought, and here it is everyone who opened or clicked a sale email since Thursday with no order since. How each segment was treated from early access onward is set out in segmenting a list for Black Friday.

Who left a checkout. Shoppers who started a checkout over the weekend and stopped are already getting the store's abandoned cart emails, if those are running. Check that a Cyber Monday campaign does not land on the same hour as their second or third reminder. The abandoned cart email piece weighs how many of those reminders to send.

Keep Friday's offer

The pull on Monday is toward a bigger discount to wake the people who have not bought. Adobe's 2026 forecast shows where the large retailers place their deepest cuts. Electronics and computers peak on Cyber Monday, while toys, televisions, apparel, appliances and furniture peak on Black Friday. For most of the categories Adobe named, the national high point is Friday.

A deeper Monday price also has a cost inside the store. It tells Friday's buyers they paid too much, and those buyers are the store's newest and warmest customers. If Monday needs something new, add something that leaves the price alone: free shipping at a lower order total, a small gift above a set amount, or a bundle of two products that sold well over the weekend. The sources cited here do not show which of these works best for a small store, so the margin on each order decides which one the store can afford.

The Cyber Monday email plan, morning to evening

A small list can close Cyber Monday with one full email and one short reminder to a smaller group. That matches the season plan in the holiday email and SMS plan, which closes the sale on Monday with one final email and keeps reminders for people who opened or clicked.

The morning email goes to the whole group of engaged subscribers who have not bought. It says the sale ends tonight and names the exact time and time zone, such as "Ends at 11:59 p.m. Pacific." It shows what is still in stock, led by the products that sold best over the weekend, and it carries one link to the sale page. Most of Adobe's Cyber Monday spending came from phones, so the end time belongs in the subject line or the first line of the email, not below a large image. The piece on holiday subject lines reviews the season's subject line wording and what research does and does not support.

The evening reminder goes only to people who opened or clicked the morning email and still have not ordered. It is short: the end time, the offer in one line, one button. Send it early in the evening in each recipient's own time zone, with enough hours left to act. Check that hour against last year's Cyber Monday orders.

Midnight Eastern cuts West Coast shoppers off at 9 p.m. their time. Midnight Pacific gives every shopper in the lower 48 states a full Monday. Whichever the store picks, the email, the website banner and the discount itself must all name the same time.

The text, if the list gets one, goes once, in the afternoon. The piece on Black Friday weekend texts makes the case for an afternoon send and explains the quiet hours setting that can push a late evening text past the deadline. Monday's text goes to the same people as the morning email, minus anyone who has bought since. Send it only to subscribers who agreed to receive marketing texts. The Federal Communications Commission's rule at 47 CFR 64.1200 calls that agreement prior express written consent: a written agreement, which an electronic signature can satisfy, that says agreeing is not a condition of buying. Growing a text list with proven consent covers what the sign up form needs.

Three settings that can cancel the last call

The details below are for whoever builds the sends in the email platform. Klaviyo is the example here. On another platform, look in its help center for any setting that skips recent recipients or sends by local time.

  • Smart Sending. This Klaviyo feature skips anyone who received a marketing email within a set window. Flow emails count too, so a shopper who got an abandoned cart reminder an hour before the morning campaign is skipped by it. Klaviyo's help center, updated in October 2026, says it is on by default for campaigns, with a default window of 16 hours for email and 24 hours for texts. Skipped messages are not rescheduled. A morning email at 9 a.m. and a reminder at 6 p.m. are nine hours apart, so the reminder skips every person who got the morning email, which is everyone it targets. Turn off Smart Sending for the reminder message alone, in the message settings or at the Recipients step.
  • Smart Sending on the other Monday sends. Check the morning email too: with a 9 a.m. Monday send, anyone emailed after 5 p.m. on Sunday is still inside the 16 hour window and gets skipped. The same 24 hour text window can skip Monday's text for anyone texted on Sunday afternoon.
  • Local time scheduling. Klaviyo can send a campaign at a set hour in each recipient's own time zone, and people whose time zone is unknown get it in the account's time zone. If that hour has already passed for some recipients when the campaign is scheduled, Klaviyo offers to send to them immediately or at the same hour the next day. On Cyber Monday, the next day is after the sale. Schedule the reminder on Monday morning with Determine recipients at send time turned on, so Klaviyo builds the list of openers and clickers just before the send instead of when the campaign is scheduled. With local time sending, Klaviyo builds that list once, before the earliest time zone sends. If the reminder is scheduled late, never choose the next day.
  • The discount's end time. In Shopify, a discount's start and end follow the time zone selected in the Shopify admin. Shopify's own example is a store on Eastern time whose discount starts at 12:00 a.m. Eastern on the chosen date. If the email promises 11:59 p.m. Pacific and the store runs on Eastern time, the discount must end at 2:59 a.m. Eastern on Tuesday.

Tuesday morning

Before the banner comes down, record three numbers for each Monday send: revenue per recipient (the sales it brought in, divided by the people it reached), unsubscribes and spam complaints. Set them beside Friday's. If the evening reminder earned little and drew complaints, next year's Monday gets one email. If it earned more per recipient than the morning send, keep both sends next year.

Then take the banner down. The discount expires on its own if the end date was set. The store's December messages begin next: shipping deadlines, the first welcome to new buyers and gift cards, which still arrive on time by email.

Frequently asked questions

When is Cyber Monday in 2026?

Cyber Monday 2026 falls on Monday, November 30, four days after Thanksgiving on November 26. Adobe forecasts $15.1 billion in online spending in the United States that day, up 6.2 percent from 2025. For a small store running a Thanksgiving weekend sale, the day usually closes an offer most of the email list has already seen.

Is Cyber Monday bigger than Black Friday?

By Adobe's count of online spending in the United States, yes: shoppers spent $14.25 billion on Cyber Monday 2025 and $11.8 billion on Black Friday. Black Friday grew faster, at 9.1 percent against 7.1 percent. Friday also drew more people. The National Retail Federation's survey estimated 85.7 million online shoppers on Black Friday and 75.9 million on Cyber Monday.

What time should a Cyber Monday sale end?

The store picks the time, and 11:59 p.m. Pacific leaves no shopper in the lower 48 states short of a full Monday. The email, the website banner and the discount need to name the same hour. In Shopify, a discount follows the time zone selected in the admin, so a store on Eastern time has to end that sale at 2:59 a.m. Tuesday.

Should a Cyber Monday discount be bigger than Black Friday?

Usually not, because a deeper Monday price tells Friday's buyers they paid too much. If Monday needs something new, free shipping at a lower order total, a small gift above a set amount or a bundle of two weekend sellers all leave the price alone. No source reviewed for this guidance shows which works best for a small store, so the margin on each order decides.

What is the best time to send a Cyber Monday email?

Send the main email in the morning and a short reminder early in the evening, with hours left to act. Adobe reported that 2025 Cyber Monday spending peaked between 8 p.m. and 10 p.m., though its release named no time zone. A store's own order times from last Cyber Monday are the better guide to its hour.

Learn More Most of a Holiday Campaign Is Decided Before the First Sale Email Places Cyber Monday's sends inside the full season's email and text calendar. Read the article
What is Klaviyo Smart Sending?

Smart Sending is a Klaviyo feature that skips anyone already sent a marketing message on the same channel within a set window. Klaviyo's help center says it is on by default for campaigns, with default windows of 16 hours for email and 24 hours for texts, and that skipped messages are not rescheduled. A reminder sent nine hours after a morning email can therefore miss everyone who got that email.

Put this to work

How Sun Locke can help

Latest from the Ledger

Continue reading

Return to the Ledger →