An extended sale reaches shoppers who are still buying in December. It also removes the deadline that made people buy on Monday, and it gives margin to buyers who needed no discount.
When Adobe publishes its Cyber Week numbers, it means five days that end on Cyber Monday: Thanksgiving, Black Friday, the weekend and the Monday itself. Those five days brought in $44.2 billion in online spending in 2025, up 7.7 percent from the year before, and Adobe forecasts $47.5 billion for 2026.
Many stores use the same name for something else. To them, Cyber Week is the week after Cyber Monday, when the sale keeps going. Adobe's Cyber Week figures say nothing about that week at all.
An owner deciding, before the first sale email goes out, whether the sale should end on November 30 has to look elsewhere. The published data on early December points two ways: shoppers keep buying, and large retailers keep discounting, though less. Whether a small store should follow depends on its deadline, its margin and what its emails already promised.
What the data says about the week after Cyber Monday
Adobe says its figures come from Adobe Analytics, which measures more than a trillion visits to American retail sites and which a majority of the country's top 100 online retailers use. The figures describe big retailers.
- Spending is spread across many days. In the 2025 season, shoppers spent more than $4 billion online on 25 separate days, up from 18 days in 2024, according to Adobe's season results published January 7, 2026.
- Discounts linger at lower depth. On December 2, 2025, Adobe said it expected deals to continue through the first week of December, down from their peaks: toys at up to 23 percent off, electronics at 19 percent and apparel at 18 percent. On Cyber Monday itself those categories had peaked at 28, 31 and 25 percent. That was Adobe's expectation for the coming week, not a measured result.
- The 2026 forecast keeps the same shape. Adobe expects discounts of up to 30 percent during its five day Cyber Week, then up to 10 to 15 percent through December.
- Most of the shopping is still ahead. The National Retail Federation (NRF) and Prosper Insights & Analytics surveyed 3,099 adults over the 2025 Thanksgiving weekend. Of those adults, 84 percent had started their holiday shopping, but they still had 53 percent of it left to do.
The customers who skipped the weekend are still shopping. The question is whether the store needs a discount to reach them.
A deadline moves purchases
The case for ending on time starts with what a deadline does. In 1994, J. Jeffrey Inman and Leigh McAlister published a study in the Journal of Marketing Research on coupon expiration dates. According to the study's abstract, the authors predicted that an expiration date creates a second wave of redemptions just before the coupon expires, then tested it on weekly coupon redemption data for spaghetti sauce from A.C. Nielsen panels in two cities. The results were consistent with the prediction. This is grocery evidence from three decades ago, read in abstract only, and not a holiday study. It describes the mechanism a "last chance" email relies on: the end date itself prompts people to act.
An extension removes that last wave. The shoppers who were about to act on Monday night learn that they did not need to.
The longer cost shows up the next year. Manohar Kalwani and Chi Kin Yim ran a controlled experiment, published in the same journal in 1992, on how promotions shape what shoppers expect. Their abstract reports that both how often a brand promotes and how deep the discounts go change the price people expect to pay. It also reports that a missing deal, when shoppers expected one, can weigh on their choice of brand more than an unexpected deal helps it.
A store whose sale reliably runs past its stated end is, by that logic, teaching its customers to wait. That is an inference from a lab study, not a measured holiday result. The cost to credibility is highest when the extension follows an email that called Monday the last chance, because the customer has now seen one of the store's deadlines move. The guide to emails after Cyber Monday warns that extending a sale because the weekend fell short makes customers less likely to believe the next deadline email.
What an extension costs in margin
The discount costs the most on sales the store would have made anyway. A hypothetical product shows the size of it. Take a product that sells for $100 and costs the store $50 to buy and ship, leaving $50 of gross profit. At 20 percent off it sells for $80 and leaves $30. To earn the same gross profit at the sale price, the store has to sell five units for every three it would have sold at full price.
In the days after Cyber Monday, some buyers would have paid full price anyway. Each of those orders now brings in $30 instead of $50. An extension pays only when the new buyers it pulls in make up for the discount given to people who did not need it.
A store can estimate that second group from its own records. Look at last year's orders from Tuesday, December 2 to Sunday, December 7, 2025, and count how many came in at full price. If that week was healthy without a discount, an extension mostly gives margin away.
There is also a cost in labor. The week after Cyber Monday is when the store packs the weekend's orders and starts working toward the carriers' holiday shipping dates. More discounted orders in that same week compete for the same hands.
Moving a deadline can mislead
In September 2022 the staff of the Federal Trade Commission published a report on manipulative website design, titled "Bringing Dark Patterns to Light." Its list of common patterns includes the "false limited time message." The report describes it as pressuring a shopper by saying a deal ends soon, but with no deadline at all, or with a meaningless one that just resets when reached. The same list includes countdown clocks that disappear or reset when they run out.
The report is a staff report, not a rule, and it does not address a single holiday extension. A store that wrote "final hours" on Monday night and ran the same offer on Tuesday should still read that description. Any extension that follows "ends tonight" wording is a question for the store's lawyer before it runs. At a minimum, a countdown clock on the site should stop when the discount stops.
When extending a Cyber Monday sale fits
An extension makes sense when it was planned before the sale began and the first email said so. If that email said the sale runs through Sunday, December 6, nothing has moved when Tuesday comes. The trade is that Monday then carries no "last chance" message, and the urgency moves to Sunday.
A store that ended its sale on Monday can still follow it with a new offer, planned in advance and presented as new rather than as the weekend sale continued.
The site failed during the sale. If shoppers could not check out, a short extension that states the reason gives them back the hours they lost. PYMNTS, a payments news site, reported on November 28, 2018, that Baublebar extended its Cyber Monday sale until Wednesday. Its apology, quoted in the report, said the response to the sale had overwhelmed its site. Shutterfly and Lenox, the report said, emailed apologies with offers to extend their sales another day.
Some stock has to go. Seasonal products such as holiday decor are much harder to sell after December 25. Discounting them in early December can cost less than clearing them in January. Narrow the offer to those products. Picking which products lead a sale is covered in the Black Friday merchandising piece, and the same judgment applies here.
A different offer can take the discount's place. Free shipping until the carrier cutoff keeps the price intact and ties the offer to a date the customer can check. Gift cards take over once shipping closes.
Ending on Monday fits most other cases. Thin margins, low stock and a list that already received a message a day all point that way. A tired list also shows up in the complaint rates Gmail and Yahoo watch; the guide to holiday email deliverability explains those limits.
Make the call before Thanksgiving
Do not decide on Tuesday morning, while looking at a weekend that fell short. Decide before the first email goes out, and write the end date into it. These questions settle most cases:
- Will the emails, texts or site say the sale ends on Monday? If so, end it on Monday.
- How much did the store sell at full price in the first week of December last year?
- Which products will not sell by December 25 without a discount?
- What is the gross profit on a typical order at the sale price?
If the store does extend, judge the result against the same December days last year, not against the weekend. A sale week usually looks weak next to Black Friday. Count unsubscribes and spam complaints for every extension send as well.
For a store that ends on Monday, the plan for that last day is in what to send on Cyber Monday.
Frequently asked questions
What is Cyber Week?
Cyber Week is a name with two meanings. Adobe uses it for five days, which in 2026 run from Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26, through Cyber Monday on November 30. Many stores use it for the week after Cyber Monday, when a sale keeps going. A store using the second meaning cannot read Adobe's figures as a measure of its own week.
How much do shoppers spend during Cyber Week?
Adobe counted $44.2 billion in online spending in the United States during its five day Cyber Week in 2025, up 7.7 percent from the year before, and forecast $47.5 billion for 2026. Those figures run from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday and come from Adobe Analytics, which measures big retailers, so they are a rough gauge for a small store.
Are fake countdown timers legal?
That depends on the facts and is a question for a lawyer, but Federal Trade Commission staff have listed them among manipulative website designs. The staff's September 2022 report, which is not a rule, names the "baseless countdown timer," a fake clock that "just goes away or resets when it times out." The report also says the agency's mission is to stop deceptive or unfair business practices.
What are dark patterns?
Dark patterns are website designs that trick or manipulate people into choices they would not otherwise make and that may cause harm, according to a September 2022 Federal Trade Commission staff report, "Bringing Dark Patterns to Light." Its examples include a maze of screens to cancel a subscription, products sneaked into a shopping cart and a deal said to end soon with no real deadline. It is a staff report and not a rule.
Do expiration dates make coupons work better?
They can prompt a burst of use just before the date, according to the abstract of one older grocery study. J. Jeffrey Inman and Leigh McAlister, writing in the Journal of Marketing Research in 1994, predicted a second wave of redemptions before expiration, and spaghetti sauce coupon data from two cities fit that prediction. The evidence is three decades old and comes from groceries, so it says nothing direct about a holiday sale.
Do stores keep discounting after Cyber Monday?
Adobe expects large retailers to keep discounting, at lower depth. On December 2, 2025, it said it expected first week of December deals of up to 23 percent on toys, 19 percent on electronics and 18 percent on apparel, below their peaks. That was an expectation and not a measured result. Adobe's 2026 forecast calls for up to 10 to 15 percent through December.
Latest from the Ledger
Continue reading
Return to the Ledger →